Are You Commoditizing Your Products?
June 16, 2009
We were at a new client’s offices recently meeting with their senior executives. One of them was talking about how their existing offering was a commodity. I remarked that if toilet paper isn’t a commodity (it isn’t), then their offering certainly wasn’t one either. It has extremely high value to their users and their method of delivery and support added value as well. He agreed and assured us yesterday that he no longer uses the term in his company.
There is a lesson in that discussion for all of us. The term “commodity” is something used by purchasing agents and procurement professionals to undermine a seller’s pricing power. Their agenda is to short-circuit any discussions about the value of your products and services. It is an act that is intentionally designed to make you think that your products and services have no value.
The problem is that salespeople hear the term commodity so much that they start believing it. Then the customer services people believe it and eventually the senior executives believe it. When everyone believes that your products and services are commodities, you have no pricing power.
How about you? Do you use the term “commodity” freely in your discussions with your people? If you do, you’re undermining your pricing power.
Here’s a bit of advice: STOP USING THE WORD COMMODITY!!!!
People use your products and services because they value them. They don’t think they are commodities because they have chosen to use them. That is a fundamental fact of doing business. Just because a buyer who has an agenda to get a lower price uses a term like commodity doesn’t mean they are right. In fact, we find that in most cases they are wrong.
If you need to, go out and talk to your real users and find out what they like about your company. Find out how they value the things you do. They’ll tell you. They’ll be glad you asked. Then, go back and make other executives stop using the word too. When anyone—ANYONE—uses the word commodity, stop and tell them that a) your products and services create high value for your customers and b) using the word commodity to describe them undermines perceptions of value with your salespeople and your customers.
In Pricing with Confidence, we use the example of how the executives from a dirt company realized that they weren’t selling a commodity. We use that example because if dirt isn’t a commodity then virtually nothing is. We use that example because too often we hear the term commodity from high value technology, software, medical equipment and financial services executives. The sad part is they honestly believe that commodity really does describe their products and services.
So, start being a value leader in your firm. Stop using the term commodity. When other people use it, tell them why they are wrong. If that doesn’t work, go to the local pet store and get one of those shock collars and start making some of the senior executives wear them–that will work.
Entry Filed under: Uncategorized. Tags: pricing, Pricing Strategy.
4 Comments Add your own
Leave a Comment
Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>
Trackback this post | Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed
1.
yoram samets | June 26, 2009 at 6:12 pm
I do not agree with this on many levels:
- as a leader you need to create friction to get movement. calling a product or service a commodity can influence change
- the customer makes the commodity product or value product decision based on their own perception of importance. Toilet paper is a commodity.
2.
Holden Advisors | June 27, 2009 at 12:32 pm
Yoram: I agree that a) a leader in an organization needs to put pressure on his or her people and that b) a customer determines the commodity status of a product but you are missing a critical point. By saying a product is a commodity the leader makes it OK for sales and pricing people to give more price discounts. Purchasing agents say high value products and services are commodities just so they can get those discounts. Is a leader better off saying that a product is a commodity when it isn’t or saying that it is high value? That’s the critical issue. Thanks for the comment.
reed
3.
Ron Baker | July 15, 2009 at 6:09 pm
Great post Reed!
As Theodore Levit proved many years ago, there is no such thing as a commodity.
From coffee, bottled water, lettuce and candles, to one share of stock and a $3,000 credit card, anything can be differentiated.
If you’re product or service is a commodity, you have lousy marketing and an even lousier value proposition.
Regards,
Ron Baker, Founder
VeraSage Institute
4.
Holden Advisors | July 17, 2009 at 2:22 pm
Thanks Ron–I just wish others could figure this out too. Hope all is well.
reed